MONIAC2 · a stepped toy model

Stuff, money, value

Every growth figure splits the pounds people spend into two parts: more stuff, and higher prices. This page shows how that split is made, and how much it depends on what statisticians decide counts as one unit of stuff. It builds up one step at a time, from a loaf of bread to the way the UK now measures telecoms.

Throughout, blue is money (pounds spent), orange is stuff (real volumes) and green is prices. Every model checks that the money splits exactly into stuff and prices.

Step 0Money = stuff × price

Start with one good. Spending on bread is the number of loaves times the price of a loaf. So, near enough, growth in spending is growth in loaves plus growth in the price.

That split is the heart of Giles Wilkes's argument about UK growth. The Bank of England steers total spending. The supply side (here, how many loaves the bakeries can make) decides how much of it becomes more stuff and how much becomes higher prices.

With one good and an obvious unit, splitting spending into stuff and prices is easy. Everything below is about what happens when it isn't.

Step 1You can't add loaves to bulbs

Now there are two goods. Pounds add up: £80 of bread plus £20 of bulbs is £100. Loaves and bulbs don't. To add them, statisticians value both at the same set of prices, and the prices they pick change the answer.

Here bulbs get cheaper every year and people buy far more of them. Move the slider to change whose prices are used, and watch real growth change, even though nothing in the world has.

So far each good comes in an obvious unit: a loaf, a bulb. The next steps ask what happens when the unit itself is the question.

Step 2What is one unit?

A chocolate bar shrinks from 200 g to 180 g and still costs £1. People buy the same 100 bars. Did anything change?

It depends on what you count. Per bar, no. Per gram, people got less chocolate and paid more for it. The money is the same either way: the unit decides how it splits.

Almost nobody argues that per gram is wrong, and UK consumer price statistics do adjust for pack size. Even per gram is a claim, though: that the last 20 g of a bar are worth as much as the first 20 g. Choosing a unit is ordinary. The next step shows it can be startling.

Step 3The bulb that lasts longer

Between 2008 and 2020, British homes swapped incandescent bulbs for LEDs, pushed along by regulation. An LED gives the same light from about a seventh of the electricity, and lasts about fifteen times as long. So what happened to the amount of lighting people bought?

Three ways to count it:

Step 4What it does to GDP and inflation

Now put lighting in a whole economy of bread and light. Lighting is a small slice of spending: the toy uses 0.72%, a long-run estimate by Tsao and colleagues. Total spending is held flat, so every change you see comes from how light is counted.

A statistical office can only re-price products it can see: bulbs and electricity. The nearest it can get to counting light is to price each bulb by the light it gives over its life. Whether any of that reaches GDP depends on where the bulbs are made.

Step 5Where does utility get in? The laptop that got better

So far, choosing a unit looked like a physical question: grams, lumens. It is really a question about what counts as the same thing, and the answer usually rests on what people value.

The "economic approach" to price indices defines the ideal consumer price index in terms of well-being: how much more money would someone need to be exactly as well off as before? Hedonic adjustment was invented to get closer to that. Its founders wanted to link prices "to a yardstick more nearly relevant to its intrinsic utility" (Adelman and Griliches, 1961, quoted by Abdirahman and colleagues, 2020).

Here, five laptop models are on sale each year. The typical one costs about £1,000 every year, while speed doubles every two years. Within any year, faster models cost more; the dial sets how much more.

Step 6When does volume track welfare?

Back to light, and one question: how much better off are people because light got cheaper? The toy knows, because its world has a stated demand curve for light. The gain is the area under that curve between the old and the new price of light, what economists call the change in consumer surplus.

Here light is counted as a product (the household view from Step 3), and lighting is 0.72% of all spending. How close do official-style measures get?

Step 7Bits: UK telecoms, 2010–2017

Between 2010 and 2017 the data moved over UK networks grew about 24-fold. Yet the official statistics of the time had the telecoms industry's real value added falling, with some of the slowest productivity growth of any industry (Abdirahman, Coyle, Heys and Stewart, 2020).

Revenue is not in doubt: Ofcom's figures have it slipping from £40.5bn to £38.1bn. The question is how to split it into stuff and prices, and that depends on what one unit of telecoms is. Diane Coyle and colleagues produced six answers, each a published price index.

Step 8Bits are mostly an input

Much of what telecoms firms sell goes to other businesses: a bank's network, a shop's card machines. So re-pricing telecoms changes two sets of figures: telecoms, which sells it, and every industry that buys it.

Since Blue Book 2021, ONS has used double deflation: each industry's real value added is its real output minus its real inputs. Before that, an industry's real value added simply followed its real output (single deflation).

CodaComputing, cloud and free goods

Further reading: Diane Coyle, GDP: A Brief but Affectionate History and The Measure of Progress; Brynjolfsson and colleagues on measuring free goods.